Fill your bellies with sweet and savory pies, hot sandwiches and other yummy treats from the baking and culinary team of Honeypie.

Did you miss PI DAY? If you didn’t stop by on 3.14, it was madness! We sold over 200 slices of pie out of our little space. Thank you everyone for your support. But the PIE doesn’t stop just because pi day is over. Our general manager Mo
Did you miss PI DAY? If you didn’t stop by on 3.14, it was madness! We sold over 200 slices of pie out of our little space. Thank you everyone for your support. But the PIE doesn’t stop just because pi day is over. Our general manager Mo is showing off our Handpie of the Month, Chorizo & Potato! Melty and delicious, it makes for the perfect breakfast or lunch snack. You can also take one frozen and heat it up later! So many PIE options, so little time.
What’s 3.14 in words? If you said PI[E] then you’re all prepped and ready to celebrate PI DAY with us!! We’ll have slices and whole pies available on Thursday 3.14, all day long. Our bakers over at @honeypie_bakeshop have been wor
What’s 3.14 in words? If you said PI[E] then you’re all prepped and ready to celebrate PI DAY with us!! We’ll have slices and whole pies available on Thursday 3.14, all day long. Our bakers over at @honeypie_bakeshop have been working OVERTIME to make sure you have the yummiest selection to choose from. Get your pie with us, or at any PIE INC location!
Are you warm enough? Sure it’s a little chilly outside, but that won’t stop us… we’re too busy enjoying our new covered and also HEATED patio! Bring your pals, your kids, or your furry kids (pets) and join us for a toasty an
Are you warm enough? Sure it’s a little chilly outside, but that won’t stop us… we’re too busy enjoying our new covered and also HEATED patio! Bring your pals, your kids, or your furry kids (pets) and join us for a toasty and TASTY time 8a-5p daily!
Breakfast got jealous of all the lunch sammies... So we added ONE MORE SAMMIE to our line up: The Bacon Cheddar Biscuit Sammie! Biscuits made from scratch from @honeypie_bakeshop, with gooey cheese and crispy bacon. Everything your weekend needs (t
Breakfast got jealous of all the lunch sammies... So we added ONE MORE SAMMIE to our line up: The Bacon Cheddar Biscuit Sammie! Biscuits made from scratch from @honeypie_bakeshop, with gooey cheese and crispy bacon. Everything your weekend needs (this one is only available on weekends for now!) Prefer sweet? Get some biscuits and blueberry jam instead. We'll have 'em, til we won't. Then we'll have 'em again next weekend!
Yet another sammie? YES! Introducing another new lunch sammie to our lineup: Blueberry Turkey! It’s super yummy and pairs perfectly with an afternoon on the (covered) patio, regardless of the weather. Gobble one up today! . #turkeysammie
Yet another sammie? YES! Introducing another new lunch sammie to our lineup: Blueberry Turkey! It’s super yummy and pairs perfectly with an afternoon on the (covered) patio, regardless of the weather. Gobble one up today! . #turkeysammie #mkeeats #bayviewmke #patioseason #pieincmke
Did you miss PI DAY? If you didn’t stop by on 3.14, it was madness! We sold over 200 slices of pie out of our little space. Thank you everyone for your support. But the PIE doesn’t stop just because pi day is over. Our general manager Mo What’s 3.14 in words? If you said PI[E] then you’re all prepped and ready to celebrate PI DAY with us!! We’ll have slices and whole pies available on Thursday 3.14, all day long. Our bakers over at @honeypie_bakeshop have been wor Are you warm enough? Sure it’s a little chilly outside, but that won’t stop us… we’re too busy enjoying our new covered and also HEATED patio! Bring your pals, your kids, or your furry kids (pets) and join us for a toasty an Breakfast got jealous of all the lunch sammies... So we added ONE MORE SAMMIE to our line up: The Bacon Cheddar Biscuit Sammie! Biscuits made from scratch from @honeypie_bakeshop, with gooey cheese and crispy bacon. Everything your weekend needs (t Yet another sammie? YES! Introducing another new lunch sammie to our lineup: Blueberry Turkey! It’s super yummy and pairs perfectly with an afternoon on the (covered) patio, regardless of the weather. Gobble one up today! . #turkeysammie

ABOUT US

We are a small, neighborhood, counter-service cafe specializing in handmade savory and sweet pies and treats.  We opened in August 2018.  We bake and make all of our treats in small batches with a lot of great Wisconsin ingredients.  Our team of chefs and bakers roll each buttery pie dough by hand for each pie just like our grandmas did, so each pie is flaky and delicious.  We have a wonderful patio for watching the neighborhood pass by.  We hope you enjoy every bite!

 

SmallPie is part of the PIE Inc team which includes our sister cafes Honeypie, Comet and Palomino as well as our baking kitchen, the Honeypie Bakeshop here in Milwaukee and in Chicago.  We believe great food, and especially great pie, is one of the best ways to make our neighborhood and city a more wonderful place.  Since 2005 we have worked hard everyday to make delicious, belly-warming food, to be a fun and healthy place to work and to bring value to our community.  Thank you for visiting!